|
|
|
This article originally appeared in
the December 2005 Harvard Men’s
Health Watch and is provided courtesy of Harvard
Health Publications.
Exercise and aging: Can you walk away from Father
Time?
The clock ticks for all men, and with each tick comes
change. For men who manage to avoid major medical problems, the changes
are slow and gradual, but they do add up. Here are some things that aging
can do to you — if you give up and let Father Time take his toll.
Some of the changes of aging start as early as the third decade of life.
After age 25–30, for example, the average man’s maximum attainable
heart rate declines by about one beat per minute, per year, and his heart’s
peak capacity to pump blood drifts down by 5%–10% per decade. That’s
why a healthy 25-year-old heart can pump 21⁄2 quarts of oxygen a minute,
but a 65-year-old heart can’t get above 11⁄2 quarts, and an
80-year-old heart can pump only about a quart, even if it’s disease-free.
In everyday terms, this diminished aerobic capacity can produce fatigue
and breathlessness with modest daily activities.
Starting in middle age, a man’s blood vessels begin to stiffen and
his blood pressure often creeps up as well. His blood itself changes, becoming
more viscous (thicker and stickier) and harder to pump through the body,
even though the number of oxygen-carrying red blood cells declines.
Most Americans begin to gain weight in midlife, putting on 3–4 pounds
a year. But since men start to lose muscle in their 40s, that extra weight
is all fat. This extra fat contributes to a rise in LDL (“bad”)
cholesterol and a fall in HDL (“good") cholesterol. It also helps
explain why blood sugar levels rise by about 6 points per decade, making
type 2 diabetes distressingly common in senior citizens.
The loss of muscle continues, eventually reducing a man’s musculature
by up to 50%, which contributes to weakness and disability. At the same
time, muscles and ligaments get stiff and tight. Although men have a lower
risk of osteoporosis (“thin bones”) than women, they do lose
bone calcium as they age, increasing the risk of fractures. One reason for
the drop in muscle mass and bone density is a drop in the male hormone testosterone,
which declines by about 1% per year after the age of 40. Though most men
continue to have normal testosterone levels and reproductive capacity throughout
life, many experience a gradual decline in libido and sexual vigor.
The nervous system also changes over time. Reflexes are slower, coordination
suffers, and memory lapses often crop up at embarrassing times. The average
person gets less sleep in maturity than in youth, even if he no longer needs
to set his alarm clock. Not surprisingly, spirits often sag as the body
slows down.
It sounds grim — and these changes happen to healthy men. Men with
medical problems start to age earlier and slow down even more. All in all,
aging is not for sissies.
No man can stop the clock, but every man can slow its tick. Research
shows that many of the changes attributed to aging are actually caused in
large part by disuse. It’s new information, but it confirms the wisdom
of Dr. William Buchan, the 18th-century Scottish physician who wrote, “Of
all the causes which conspire to render the life of a man short and miserable,
none have greater influence than the want of proper exercise.” And
about the same time, the British poet John Gay agreed: “Exercise thy
lasting youth defends.”
Exercise is not the fountain of youth, but it is a good long drink of
vitality, especially as part of a comprehensive program (see box below).
And a unique study from Texas shows just how important exercise can be.
The Dallas Bed Rest and Training Study
In 1966, five healthy men volunteered for a research study at the University
of Texas Southwestern Medical School. It must have sounded like the opportunity
of a lifetime; all they had to do was spend three weeks of their summer
vacation resting in bed. But when they got out of bed at the end of the
trial, it probably didn’t seem so good. Testing the men before and
after exercise, the researchers found devastating changes that included
faster resting heart rates, higher systolic blood pressures, a drop in the
heart’s maximum pumping capacity, a rise in body fat, and a fall in
muscle strength.
In just three weeks, these 20-year-olds developed many physiologic characteristics
of men twice their age. Fortunately, the scientists didn’t stop there.
Instead, they put the men on an 8-week exercise program. Exercise did more
than reverse the deterioration brought on by bed rest, since some measurements
were better than ever after the training.
The Dallas study was a dramatic demonstration of the harmful consequences
of bed rest. It’s a lesson that’s been learned yet again in
the era of space travel, and it has helped change medical practice by encouraging
an early return to physical activity after illness or surgery. And by revisiting
the question 30 years later, the Texas researchers have also been able to
investigate the interaction between exercise and aging.
A second look
The original subjects all agreed to be evaluated again at the age of
50. All five remained healthy, and none required long-term medication. Even
so, the 30-year interval had not been kind. Over the years, the men gained
an average of 50 pounds, or 25% of their weight at age 20. Their average
body fat doubled from 14% to 28% of body weight. In addition, their cardiac
function suffered, with a rise in resting heart rate and blood pressure
and a fall in maximum pumping capacity. In terms of cardiac function, though,
the toll of time was not as severe as the toll of inactivity; at 50, the
men were far below their 20-year-old best, but they were not quite as feeble
as when they emerged from three weeks of bed rest in 1966.
The researchers did not ask the 50-year-old volunteers to lie in bed
for three weeks; that could have been hazardous. But they did ask them to
begin an exercise program, and they wisely constructed a gradual 6-month
regimen of walking, jogging, and cycling instead of the 8-week crash course
that served the 20-year-olds so well.
Slow but steady endurance training carried the day. At the end of the
six months, the men averaged only a modest 10-pound loss of their excess
weight, but their resting heart rates, blood pressures, and their heart’s
maximum pumping abilities were back to their baseline level from age 20.
All in all, exercise training reversed 100% of the 30-year age-related decline
in aerobic power. Even so, exercise did not take the men back to their peak
performance after 8 weeks of intense training at age 20. The clock does
tick, after all, but exercise did slow the march of time.
The Dallas scientists contributed a great deal to our understanding of
exercise and aging, but they did not seize the opportunity to evaluate many
of the changes that men experience as they age. Fortunately, other research
has filled in the gaps. To avoid gaps as you age, construct a balanced exercise
program.
Endurance training. As the Texas studies showed, endurance exercise is
the best way to improve cardiovascular function. It helps keep the heart
muscle supple and the arteries flexible, lowers the resting heart rate,
and boosts the heart’s peak ability to deliver oxygen-rich blood to
the body’s tissues. A related benefit is a fall in blood pressure.
Endurance exercise is also the best way to protect the body’s metabolism
from the effects of age. It reduces body fat, sensitizes the body’s
tissues to insulin, and lowers blood sugar levels. Exercise boosts the HDL
(“good”) cholesterol and lowers levels of LDL (“bad”)
cholesterol and triglycerides. And the same types of activity will fight
some of the neurological and psychological changes of aging. Endurance exercise
boosts mood and improves sleep, countering anxiety and depression. In addition,
it improves reflex time and helps stave off age-related memory loss. All
in all, many of the changes that physiologists attribute to aging are actually
caused by disuse. Using your body will keep it young (see table below).
The Dallas investigators prescribed walking, jogging, and biking for
endurance training. They could have achieved the same benefits with swimming,
racquet sports, rowing, cross-country skiing, aerobic dance, and even golf
(as long as players walk the course). A variety of exercise machines can
also do the job, but only if you use them properly. The key is regular activity.
Start slowly if you are out of shape, then build up gradually to 3–4
hours a week. A program as simple as 30 minutes of brisk walking nearly
every day will produce major benefits. :
| Exercise vs. aging |
| |
Effect of aging |
Effect of exercise |
| Heart and circulation |
| Resting heart rate |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Maximum heart rate |
Decrease |
Slows the decrease |
| Maximum pumping capacity |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Heart muscle stiffness |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Blood vessel stiffness |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Blood pressure |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Blood |
| Number of red blood cells |
Decrease |
No change |
| Blood viscosity (“thickness”) |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Lungs |
| Maximum oxygen uptake |
Decrease |
No change |
| Intestines |
| Speed of emptying |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Bones |
| Calcium content and strength |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Muscles |
| Muscle mass and strength |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Metabolism |
| Metabolic rate |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Body fat |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Blood sugar |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Insulin levels |
Increase |
Decrease |
| LDL (“bad”) cholesterol |
Increase |
Decrease |
| HDL (“good”) cholesterol |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Sex hormone levels |
Decrease |
Slight decrease |
| Nervous system |
| Nerve conduction and reflexes |
Slower |
Decrease |
| Quality of sleep |
Decrease |
Increase |
| Risk of depression |
Increase |
Decrease |
| Memory lapses |
Increase |
Decrease |
Resistance exercise using light weights or exercise machines
will enhance muscle mass and strength and preserve bone calcium. You’ll
need to learn what to do, and instructors can help. But with simple directions
and precautions, most men can develop a safe and effective home program
for themselves.
Flexibility training will help keep you supple as you age. Stretching
exercises are an ideal way to warm up before and cool down after endurance
exercise. Like strength training, 20 minutes of dedicated time two or three
times a week is ideal. Yoga classes are very helpful, but most men can learn
to stretch for health on their own.
Exercises for balance will also help retard some common effects of aging.
They will help you move gracefully, avoid injuries, and prevent the falls
that cripple so many older Americans.
Helen Hayes was right when she proclaimed, “Resting is rusting.” But
although exercise can do much to remove the rust of aging, it can’t
do it all. Even a balanced exercise program won’t keep reading glasses
off a man’s nose or prevent cataracts from forming in due time. Exercise
can’t keep a man’s prostate small or his testosterone levels
high, but it can reduce his risk of erectile dysfunction.
To keep your body as young as possible for as long as possible, keep
it moving. As usual, Hippocrates got it right about 2,400 years ago, explaining, “That
which is used develops; that which is not wastes away.”
Exercise, illness, and longevity
A proper exercise program will help men delay many of the changes of
aging, particularly when they combine it with other preventive measures
(see “Not by exercise alone,” below). And the same program can
help ward off many of the chronic illnesses that too often tarnish a man’s
golden years.
Heart disease is the leading killer of American men. Because exercise
helps improve so many cardiac risk factors (cholesterol, blood pressure,
diabetes, obesity, and stress), it should have a powerful protective influence
on heart attacks — and it does. Back in 1978, the Harvard Alumni Study
found that men who exercise regularly are 39% less likely to suffer heart
attacks than their sedentary peers. It was a groundbreaking observation,
and it’s been confirmed many times over.
Stroke is the third leading cause of death in America. Like heart disease,
many strokes are caused by atherosclerosis, which is why heart attacks and
stroke share so many risk factors. It’s no surprise, then, that exercise
can reduce the risk of stroke. Twenty-four years after its report on exercise
and heart disease, the Harvard Alumni Study linked mild exercise to a 24%
risk reduction; moderate to intensive exercise was even better, reducing
risk by 46%.
Cancer is different — but exercise can also help fight the nation’s
second leading killer. Colon cancer is the clearest example; Harvard’s
Health Professionals Follow-Up Study found that highly active men are 47%
less likely to develop the disease than their sedentary peers, and many
other studies agree. Although the evidence is far less conclusive, regular
exercise may even help prevent prostate cancer.
Exercise precautions
Exercise is wonderful for health — but to get gain without pain, you
must do it wisely, using restraint and judgment every step of the way. Here
are a few tips:
Get a medical check-up before you begin a moderate to vigorous exercise
program, particularly if you are older than 40, if you have medical problems,
or if you have not exercised previously. Although treadmill stress tests
were once considered an important precaution, they are not necessary for
most people who are healthy, even if they are senior citizens. But even
if stress tests before exercise are not useful for healthy men, they are
mandatory for anyone with heart disease or symptoms that suggest problems.
Eat and drink appropriately. Don’t eat for two hours before you exercise,
but drink plenty of water before, during, and after exercise, particularly
in warm weather.
Warm up before you exercise and cool down afterward. Stroll before you
walk, and walk before you jog. Stretches and light calisthenics are ideal
warm-up and cool-down activities.
Dress simply, aiming for comfort, convenience, and safety rather than
style.
Use good equipment, especially good shoes.
Exercise regularly. Unless you are ill or injured, try to exercise nearly
every day, but alternate harder workouts with easier ones. Give yourself
enough time to recover from injuries and illness — and remember that
recovery may take longer as you age.
Explore a variety of activities to find what suits you best. Variety
will keep your muscles fresh and will keep you from getting stale or bored.
Build a well-rounded program. Add strength training, stretches, and exercises
for balance to your basic endurance exercise. Consider getting instruction
or joining a health club.
Exercise safely. It makes little sense to reduce your risk of heart attack
or stroke by increasing your risk of accidental injury or death. Adjust
your routine in weather that is hot, cold, or wet.
Listen to your body. Learn warning signals of heart disease, including
chest pain or pressure, disproportionate shortness of breath, fatigue, or
sweating, erratic pulse, lightheadedness, or even indigestion. Do not ignore
aches and pains that may signify injury; early treatment can often prevent
more serious problems. Do not exercise if you are feverish or ill. Work
yourself back into shape gradually after a layoff, particularly after illness
or injury.
Helping to prevent heart disease, cancer, stroke — exercise is worth
the effort. And there’s more. Physical activity can help reduce your
risk for many of the chronic illnesses that produce so much distress and
disability as men age. The list includes hypertension, diabetes, osteoporosis,
and even Alzheimer’s disease. It also includes “minor” ailments
such as painful gallbladder attacks and bothersome symptoms of benign prostatic
hyperplasia. And if that’s not enough motivation, consider that the
Health Professionals Study linked regular exercise to a 30% reduction in
a man’s risk of impotence.
Regular exercise helps people age more slowly and live healthier, more
vigorous lives. And it also helps people live longer. Calculations based
on the Harvard Alumni Study suggest that men who exercise regularly can
gain about two hours of life expectancy for each hour of exercise. Over
the course of a lifetime, that adds up to about two extra years. Maximum
benefit does require regular exercise over the years, but it doesn’t
mean a trip to the gym every day. In fact, just 30 minutes of brisk walking
every day will go a long way toward enhancing your health.
Calculations are one thing, observations another. Scientists have evaluated
men in Hawaii, Seventh-day Adventists in California, male and female residents
of Framingham, Massachusetts, elderly American women, British joggers, middle-aged
Englishmen, retired Dutchmen, and residents of Copenhagen, among others.
Although the details vary, the essential message is remarkably uniform:
Regular exercise prolongs life and reduces the burden of disease and disability
in old age. In reviewing the data, Dr. J. Michael McGinnis of the Office
of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion (U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services) concludes that regular physical activity appears to reduce
the overall mortality rate by more than a quarter and to increase the life
expectancy by more than two years compared with the sedentary population’s
average.
Do the stronger live longer?
Insurance agents are not alone; doctors would also like to predict disability
and longevity. Scientists working with the Honolulu Heart Program and the
Honolulu-Asia Aging Study proposed a simple way to do just that. Between
1965 and 1970, they evaluated about 8,000 healthy men with an average age
of 54. Each volunteer was tested for his maximal handgrip strength along
with conventional risk factors. The scientists tracked the men for an average
of 25 years. During that time, 37% of the men died; the survivors were 71–93
years of age. Grip strength in midlife did not predict longevity, but it
did correlate with disability. The men who were strongest in middle age
had the lowest risk of disabilities and dependency in old age, even after
chronic illnesses were taken into account.
Cardiovascular fitness and aerobic capacity do predict longevity. In
the Hawaiian study, muscular strength did not, but it did predict infirmity
in old age.
It’s never too late
One of the most impressive things about the Dallas Bed Rest and Training
Study was that the men responded nearly as well to exercise training at
50 as they did at 20. In fact, men can benefit from exercise at any age,
though senior citizens do need to take extra care, especially if they are
just getting started. Perhaps the most dramatic example comes from a Harvard
study that demonstrated important improvements in 87- to 90-year-old nursing
home patients who were put on a weight-lifting program. This study evaluated
muscular function, but the Harvard Alumni Study examined mortality. The
latter study found that previously sedentary men who began exercising after
the age of 45 enjoyed a 24% lower death rate than their classmates who remained
inactive. The maximum benefits were linked to an amount of exercise equivalent
to walking for about 45 minutes a day at about 17 minutes per mile. On average,
sedentary people gained about 1.6 years of life expectancy from becoming
active later in life.
Studies from Harvard, Norway, and England all confirm the benefits of
exercise later in life. It’s important research, but it confirms the
wisdom of the Roman poet Cicero, who said, “No one is so old that
he does not think he could live another year.”
Not by exercise alone
Exercise is one way to slow the aging process, but it works best in combination
with other measures. Here are some other tips to help you age well:
Avoid tobacco in all its forms.
Eat properly. Reduce your consumption of saturated fat, trans fatty acids,
and cholesterol. The omega-3s and monounsaturated fats in fish, nuts, olive
oil, and possibly canola oil are desirable in moderation. Eat lots of fruits,
vegetables, whole grains, and nonfat dairy products. Favor complex carbohydrates
and high-fiber foods, but reduce your consumption of simple sugars. Get
about 15% of your calories from protein. Cut back on salt and processed
foods. Keep your caloric consumption down and stay as lean as possible.
Consider simple supplements such as a daily multivitamin and low-dose
aspirin (81 mg a day).
If you choose to drink, be responsible, and limit yourself to two drinks
a day.
Keep your mind active and stimulated. Mental exercise is an important
complement to physical exercise.
Build strong social networks. People are good medicine at any age.
Get regular medical care. Good medicine is good medicine.
A balanced program is best. That’s why Cicero proclaimed, “Exercise
and temperance will preserve something of our youthful vigor, even into
old age.”
Beat the clock
Aging is inevitable, but it has an undeservedly fearsome reputation.
No man can stop the clock, but most can slow its tick and enjoy life as
they age with grace and vigor. Jonathan Swift was right when he said, “Every
man desires to live long, but no man would be old.” Regular exercise,
along with a good diet, good medical care, good genes, and a bit of luck,
can make it happen.
Exercise and longevity — it’s Darwin redux: The survival of
the fittest.
|
 |
|
 |